Trademark Objection Reply in India

Updated on January 20, 2025 05:53:43 PM

In India, a trademark is one of the most important assets that guarantee protection to a brand's identity and its intellectual property. However in the process of trademark registration sometimes may encounter difficulties in form of trademark objection raised in process of examination phase. when the trademark office examine carefully trademark application for various deficiencies such as similarity of marks, non-distinctiveness of marks, and incorrect classification, among other possible deficiencies that may be noticed in new registration applications.

Understanding the "Objected" status in trademark and creating a strong reply to a trademark objection is an important part to make sure your trademark registers successfully. In this article, we will take you through the completed procedure on how to reply to a trademark objection, along with the reason and cost involved with them, so that you can confidently navigate legal complexities with clarity and confidence. At Litem Legalis we’re here to resolve trademark objections with care and expertise, ensuring a strong and clear reply to help secure your trademark

table content image

What is a Trademark?

Before addressing trademark objections it is crucial that we understand what exactly a trademark is. A conventional definition of a trademark in India is something distinctive by way of a sign, design, or expression that goods or services offered by a business are different from that offered by others. A trademark is distinctive and unique and different from others; it speaks about the reputation and quality of a brand and ownership.

Trademark registration gives the owner exclusive rights in its use, while any use by third parties without permission is prohibited. Legal protection will guarantee the integrity of the brand and protect it against any infringement.

What Does Trademark Objection Mean?

The stage of a 'trademark objection' is a crucial phase in the process of registration, as it is an indication that the Registrar of Trademarks, examiner, or a third party has raised specific issues/concerns during the examination process. It ensures that trademarks meet the legal criteria and will not affect anyone's rights. An objection in a trademark registration process doesn't essentially mean a refusal of your application. Instead, it signals the need for a well-prepared reply to address the objections raised, through which the application will move forward with the procedure of registration.


There are two major opportunities for third parties to lodge objection to a trademark registration, resulting in the “objected” status:

  • When the Mark appears in the Trademark Journal:  Upon completing the initial examination successfully, the application gets published in the Trademark Journal and the public-opposition period starts inviting representations of opposition by the public

  • When the Applicant Uses the Mark Before Registration:   If an applicant starts to use the mark before he/she registers the mark, then a third party raises concerns, the application may be changed to 'Adv Before Acceptance.

Upon filing an objection, the application status is set to “Opposed”.The party who objects to the trademark will need to clearly state the ground for their objection. which may include

  • The similarity of the mark to an existing trademark.
  • It is the ability to mislead or defraud the public.
  • Non-compliance with the provisions of the Trade Marks Act.

This Act ensures that fairness is maintained by allowing the applicant to defend their trademark through a structured process and if necessary attending a hearing to resolve the objections.

Reasons for Trademark Objections

The Indian Trademark Office may object to a trademark application under Section 9 and Section 11 of the Indian Trademarks Act. Common reasons include lack of distinctiveness, being overly descriptive or generic, or conflicting with already registered or pending trademarks.These objections can arise on relative grounds or absolute grounds. Below are the key reasons for trademark objections:

Grounds for Objection to Trademark Application under Section 9 and Section 11 of the Indian Trademarks Act. Common grounds for refusal are not distinctive, being too descriptive,generic, or being in conflict with existing or applied for trademarks. These objections can be relative or absolute ground. Here are the Top Reasons for trademark objection:

  1. Relative Grounds for Objection (Section 11)

    Relative grounds objections result when the new proposed trademark is likely to be confused with existing trademarks due to name, sound or concept.

    • Identical Marks: If the mark is the same as a mark that has been registered for same or similar goods and services.
      • Example: Applying for "GlowCare" for the beverages section and when "GlowCare" has already been created in the same section.

    • Similar Sound: Accents that give sounds the same pronunciation need to be looked at differently even if the spelling is different.
      • Example: "EasyPay" compared to "EzeePay" for candy products.

    • Similar Concept: Marks conveying the same idea or theme may be objectionable.
      • Example: "SmartTech" versus "TechSmart" for IT services.

  2. Absolute Grounds for Objection (Section 9)

    Objections on absolute grounds focus on the inherent nature of the trademark and its compliance with legal standards.

    • Lack of Distinctiveness: Trademarks that fail to distinguish the goods or services from others in the market.
      • Example: A simple star icon for jewelry products.

    • Descriptive Terms: Trademarks that directly describe the product or service may not be registrable.
      • Example: "CoolWater" for bottled water.

    • Deceptive or Misleading Marks:  Marks that can mislead consumers about the product’s nature, quality, or origin.
      • Example: "PureSilk" for clothing made of synthetic fabric.

  3. Trademark Examination Report

    If objections are raised while the trademark is being registered, these document are recorded in a Trademark Examination Report. In addition, these report indicates the basis of the objections and the provisions of the Trademark Act under which such objections are raised.To move forward with the registration applicants need to submit well drafted reply that directly addresses any objections raised .

    This is important because it allows the applicant to clear the hurdles to the registration and get their exclusive rights to the trademark.

Documents Required for Trademark Objection Reply

To effectively address objections raised during the trademark registration process, the following documents must be included in the reply:

  • Invoices and Bills:  Proof of the trademark's use in commercial transactions.

  • Affidavits:  Declarations confirming the use and ownership of the trademark.

  • Business Cards and Letterheads:  Evidence of the trademark's integration into business operations.

  • Government Certificates:  Relevant documents, such as MSME or FSSAI certificates, support the legitimacy of the business.

  • Marketing Proof:  Screenshots of social media pages or copies of advertisements showcasing the trademark.

  • Authorization (Form TM-48):   Authorization letter permitting an attorney or agent to act on behalf of the applicant.

  • Examination Report or Application Number:   A copy of the Trademark Examination Report or the corresponding application number.

  • Supporting Evidence of Commercial Use:  Documents demonstrating the trademark’s active use in the marketplace.

How to File a Trademark Objection Reply?

A trademark objection is a critical step to getting your trademark registered. When you receive the Trademark Examination Report, you need to act fast and have a well drafted reply to the objections raised. If a response is not filed within the specified time, the application will be rejected.

Here’s a step-by-step guide to responding effectively:Here’s a step-by-step guide to responding effectively:

Step 1: Review the Examination Report

Once you receive the objection notice (examination report), the first step is to thoroughly analyze the objections raised. These objections are typically based on legal grounds such as similarity to existing trademarks, lack of distinctiveness, or failure to meet specific requirements under the Trade Marks Act.

Step 2: File a Counter Statement

Submit a counter statement within two months from the date of receiving the notice of objection. This document should:

  • Address each objection in detail.
  • Reference relevant provisions of the Trademark Act and judicial precedents.
  • Highlight the distinctiveness of the mark if objected under Section 9 or establish no conflict with existing marks under Section 11.

Step 3: Attach Supporting Documents

Strengthen your reply by attaching evidence such as:

  • Invoices and Bills: To prove the trademark's commercial use.
  • Marketing Material:Advertisements, social media posts, or website screenshots.
  • Affidavits:Confirming the mark’s use and relevance.
  • Government Certifications: Supporting your business's authenticity.

Step 4: Hearing (If Required)

After submitting the reply, the Registrar may schedule a hearing. At this stage:

  • Present your case effectively, highlighting why the trademark qualifies for registration.
  • Address any additional queries raised by the Registrar.

Suppose the Registrar is satisfied with the arguments and evidence. In that case, the trademark will proceed to be published in the Trademark Journal, where the public can review and raise objections within a four-month window.

Step 5: Appeal Process

If the reply is not accepted by the Registrar, the applicant may appeal to Intellectual Property Appellate Board (IPAB). Key points to note:

  • The appeal must be filed within three months of the Registrar’s order.
  • If filed late, a petition for condonation of delay must accompany the appeal with valid reasons and a fee.
  • The case is heard based on the submissions of both parties.

The IPAB’s decision is legally valid and if you does not satisfy with it you can further appeal to the High court and later to the Supreme court of India

Conclusion

In the end, trademark registration in India is a process where responding to a trademark objection is very important in registration process. while facing objections is a complex procedure, but knowing about grounds for objections and proper objection procedure can increase the probablity of registration. However, applicants can protect their brand identity and defend their intellectual property rights if they provide a clear, well documented response to the Trademark Examiner's objections. An experienced trademark lawyer will help you in this process and avoid unnecessary hassles that can take place in case you do not have the right documentation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What happens if I don’t reply to a trademark objection?

Failing to reply can result in the abandonment of your application.

Can I handle a trademark objection reply on my own?

While it is possible but seeking professional assistance significantly improves your chances of success.

What is trademark opposition reply?

A trademark opposition reply is a formal response filed by the applicant to defend their trademark against objections raised during the opposition process.

Get In Touch

Support

Speak Directly to our Expert Today

Disclaimer: The content provided on this site is intended for informational purposes only. Accessing or utilizing this site and its materials does not establish an attorney-client relationship. The information contained herein does not constitute legal or professional advice and should not be relied upon as such. It is not a substitute for obtaining legal counsel from a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction